How to Make Potting Soil and Seed Starter Mixes

Hi, I’m Gardener Scott and today I’ll discuss how to make your own potting soil and seed starter mix, and I’ll share my recipes. For many gardeners one bag of seed starter mix or potting soil is enough to start a few seeds or to pot up a few plants, but if you plan to do a lot, a lot of flats of seeds or maybe transplanting a lot of plants, you’re going to need a lot of bags and that can get expensive real fast. You can save money and I recommend making your own if you’re going to be doing a lot. If you look at the ingredients of your seed starter mix or your potting soil you’ll find that they almost always rely on peat moss and my recipes do the same. Perlite and vermiculite are also very common ingredients. You can find these at most nursery centers. I tend to buy in bulk. These 4-cubic foot bags really don’t cost much more than about $20, if you buy them online and they’ll last a long time. A seed starter mix really doesn’t need to include much in the way of nutrients. You don’t need fertilizers at all. A seed contains everything it needs to start growing. All you need to do is just provide a place that’s warm, that has moisture, and the seed will start growing and so the medium can really be quite simple. Peat moss and perlite Is all I use. So my basic mix is two parts peat moss to one part perlite. A simple matter, just dump in two scoops of peat moss and one scoop of perlite. Now the perlite can be quite powdery and it will actually drift up into the air, so if you do this a lot, and you’re making a big mix, you might want to wear a dust mask. I typically will stand up when I put the perlite in so that as it drops the dust will kind of settle low. And I let the dust settle before I get back and start mixing it, but for demonstration purposes Ii’s just a simple matter of 2 to 1. Now, you can keep track, so I can go 1 2, 3, 4, 1, 2, Whatever works for you. And the measurements don’t have to be perfect, they don’t have to be exact. When I’m making a lot like this tub, I’ll actually forego these specific measurements and I’ll just dump in a bunch of peat moss and then I’ll take the bag of perlite and I’ll try to put in about half as much. And that’s it at this point. I just mix it by hand, just trying to combine the two ingredients so that it’s pretty evenly distributed. Adding water is the last step. The peat moss is pretty dry and you’ll need to add water to make the entire mix nice and moist. So what’s so great about this magical mixture of just peat moss and perlite? Well you want your seeds to stay moist so that they can germinate. That’s where the peat moss comes in. It has an ability to hold and retain a great amount of water. And so the seeds have a nice place where the roots can start growing in a moist environment, but you don’t want your seed mix to be too wet because the seeds could rot. That’s where the perlite comes in. It’s great at drainage, so the mix between the moisture holding contents of the peat moss and the drainage ability of the perlite, actually is pretty magical and they work very well together. There is an alternative to peat moss you could use coir. Coir is made from the husks of coconuts and typically comes in a compressed brick or block. This is an alternative. It achieves the same purpose that holds a great amount of water. You do need to rehydrate these bricks before you could use them to make a seed starter mix or a potting mix, but it’s definitely an alternative and some that I sometimes use. It’s just the coir tends to be more expensive than the same amount of peat moss. When it’s time to transplant seedlings into a bigger pot, a seed starter mix doesn’t have much in the way of nutrients that plants need, so it’s time to use a potting mix. A potting mix is a little more substantial, little more robust, has more nutrients, and so you can either buy a potting mix or make your own. But you do need to have more than just peat moss and perlite. The key difference between the seed starter mix and the potting soil mix is the addition of compost. I use bag compost. It works better for me in this environment with the quantities that I make. You could also use your own compost. I’d recommend sifting it. You could use worm castings. The idea is just to add a nutrition component at this point to the mix and give yourself, your plants, something that they can benefit from. At this point I start adding the three ingredients to my tub. The ratio changes. I use three parts of peat moss, three parts of compost, two parts of perlite. I put them in my tub and start mixing. Additional nutrients in the potting soil mix comes from blood meal, bone meal, and green sand. The blood meal offers the plants nitrogen, the bone meal provides phosphorus, and the green sand provides potassium. For a tub this size I’ll add about a quarter cup of the blood meal, the bone meal, and the green sand and then incorporate it very well. If you’re making a smaller quantity you don’t need nearly that much. It doesn’t take much more than maybe a tablespoon of each of these ingredients are or at least one of these ingredients to make your potting soil more robust and more substantial. Just like before, when you have everything in your tub or your container, you want to blend it and mix it well to fully incorporate all of the ingredients. So where does the vermiculite fit in? Well, vermiculite and perlite are similar. Perlite helps with drainage and vermiculite helps with drainage, but vermiculite also has the ability to hold some moisture and so sometimes in my seed starter mix I’ll actually use vermiculite along with the perlite in the recipe. In the potting soil mix I’ll do the same thing. I’ll use three parts of peat moss, three parts of compost, one part of perlite, and one part of vermiculite. And there you have it. That’s how I make my seed starter mix and how I make my potting soil mix. The exact ratios aren’t critical. And if you do a search of the net you’ll find that there’s a lot of recipes out there. These recipes work for me. I’ve had great success I encourage that you try the basic recipes, modify them as you see fit and basically come down to what you like best. Ultimately you’ll save money. You might enjoy yourself and you have some fun, just making your own soil for your own seeds and your own plants. I’m Gardener Scott. Thanks for joining me today. Enjoy gardening.

16 thoughts on “How to Make Potting Soil and Seed Starter Mixes

  1. I’ve watched dozens of videos and all I needed to know was how to make transplanting soil for my seedlings. This was the only video I found. It’s fantastic. Thank you so much.

  2. Hi Scott! Thank you for the video. My husband and I grow our own food and will be selling plants 🌱 as well. Your video is most helpful. I have been mixing just peat moss and perlite and a little soil underneath sometimes but just the two part mix on the top. 😀 Thanks for confirming that for me. I am going to start moistening the mixture before though. Thanks for the tips.Happy gardening brother. 😉

  3. And does this mix have to sit for a few weeks or can you use it right away?
    Thank you so much for the video😁 it was super helpful!

  4. hello gardner scott what confuse me is the type of compost suitable of creating potting mix and do i need to fertilize although i have compost applied to the mix later on?

  5. I tried your seed starting mix (peat and perlite) this year and had dismal results. Right off the batt, comparing it to Jiffy seed starting mix and Pro-mix BK 25, the seeds took about 3-5 days longer to germinate. But the worst part was that after the seedlings grew their first set of true leaves, the leaves started to turn yellow and the plants' growth would pretty much halt. I tried this mix with a variety of seeds (tomatoes, zucchini, peppers, etc). I was able to save some seedlings by transplanting them into a good medium, but most I just threw out. The recovery took over 2 weeks for those plants I tried to save.

    I am not 100% sure why this happened, but I suspect that it is because the peat/perlite recipe has no nutritional value and the peat is too acidic. While it may be true that a seed contains all the nutrients for a seedling, once it germinates and starts to set it's true leaves, you need nutrients in the soil.

    I think a way to correct this recipe is to add some compost to the mix. But after all this work and given the terrible results, I am just going to go back to using Jiffy and Promix BK25. The BK25 is not organic, though. But I can get it really cheap at a local nursery and it comes out to be MUCH cheaper than the jiffy mix, per quart. Jiffy costs me about $0.52 per quart and a 2.8 cu. ft. bag of BK 25 only costs me about $0.33 per quart. 1 cu. ft. = 72 dry quarts in case you are wondering.

    The reason I will not try adding compost to this recipe myself is because I grow all my plants in my home and using compost indoors (in the past) has lead to fungus gnat infestations in my home, which spread to my house plants. It took a lot of effort and time to save my house plants from this ordeal.

    So in the end, I have decided that a reasonably priced starter mix that performs well is worth way more to me than trying to save a few pennies. If I can find Jiffy seed starting mix in bulk so as to get it closer to the price I can get for the BK25, I will definitely use Jiffy instead since it is organic.

    These Youtube gardening channels are great, but I find that most of the info on them has to be taken with a grain of salt. But you'll never know until you try it, I guess.

  6. Very informative video that really make the concept clear for making potting mix and seed raising mix with demonstration no one did before.

  7. Hi Scott, enjoy what your sharing🌱 Look forward to checking more out and asking questions when they arise. I see you get back to your followers, I like that. What part of our planet 🌎 are you located (short growing season)☀️🍅🍓✨

  8. I heard perlite is not doing anything to the soil but that after a long time it make the medium worse. I do add rock dust in the potting mix. I use both coco peat and peat moss pH is a bit high in coco and a bit low in peat moss. I might try to mix coco and pet moss to to fine tune the pH value.

  9. Anyway what I am/was looking for without succes. Is amendments for seedling soil. I use coco peat rinsed and buffered. I know a guy that have brilliant results with the seedling soil but he is keeping he's recipe to himself. I think he is added lava rockdust, maybe silica maybe kelp power. I'm experimenting myself to come to conclusion. A bit of aloe gel maybe as well. Thanks for your reply Niklas.

  10. Glad I found your site , your the no nonsense guy, some are a little to crazy for me, I’m sixty, and those young bloods are to much for this old guy, again very happy to have found your site, and thank you…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *